Your Right to Legal Counsel After Initial Consultation When Detained in Canada

Being detained by law enforcement can be a stressful and unfamiliar experience. One of your fundamental legal rights during this process is the right to counsel. This post explores the nuances of your right to consult with a lawyer after an initial conversation, following your arrest or detention in Canada.

The Right to Counsel in Canada: Section 10(b)

The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the right to speak to a lawyer without delay when you’re arrested or detained and to be informed of this right under Section 10(b). Typically, this right is considered fulfilled once you’ve been given the initial chance to contact a lawyer.

If you are facing criminal charges, securing the services of a qualified criminal lawyer is paramount. A criminal lawyer can advise you of your legal rights, navigate the complexities of the legal system, and advocate for your best interests throughout the proceedings. Call (855) 585-1777 for a free consultation with a criminal lawyer.

General Rules

Initially, detainees get a one-time opportunity to consult a lawyer, except under specific conditions. Further access to a lawyer depends on the police’s discretion, unless the situation changes significantly during the detention (R. v. Briscoe, [2012]). This rule generally applies to a single period of detention and does not extend to new interactions related to the same case (R. v. TGH, [2014]).

Exceptions to Limited Re-Consultation

The general principle may restrict access to counsel, but there are established exceptions:

  • New or Unusual Procedures: If the police request your participation in a novel investigative procedure, such as a lineup or polygraph test, you have the right to consult with a lawyer again before deciding.
  • Increased Charges: If new charges are laid against you, or the severity of existing charges escalates, you are entitled to speak with a lawyer again to discuss the altered circumstances.
  • Improper Waiver: If your initial waiver of the right to counsel was not obtained correctly, you may be able to consult with a lawyer again.

These exceptions are not exhaustive, and specific circumstances may warrant extra legal consultation. A qualified lawyer can advise you of your rights, navigate the legal system, and fight for your best interests. Call (855) 585-1777 for a free consultation.

Change in Circumstances Exception

If your situation changes noticeably and you need new legal advice, you may be entitled to consult your lawyer again. This is crucial for receiving appropriate guidance as your case evolves.

Change of Jeopardy

If there are new charges or changes in your case that significantly affect your legal standing, you should be allowed to consult with your lawyer again. This updated legal advice is vital for making informed decisions. However, it’s important to remember that not all changes will qualify for additional legal consultation; it depends on the nature of the changes and the discretion of the police.

Subsequent Access to Counsel

While the right to counsel is enshrined in the Charter, the ability to consult with a lawyer again after the initial conversation can be limited. You have a limited right to speak with your lawyer again if the situation in your case changes significantly, making further legal advice necessary. This principle was established in the landmark case R. v. Sinclair [2010].

Exercising Your Right to Re-Consultation

If you believe new developments necessitate speaking with a lawyer again after your initial consultation, politely but firmly inform the police officer of your desire to consult with legal counsel.

Contact a Trusted Criminal Lawyer

Call (855) 585-1777 to speak with an experienced criminal lawyer who is dedicated to crafting client-centred solutions. We will guide you through the legal process and help you deal with your criminal charge at each step along the way.

Scroll to Top